Fish culvert in Issaquah. (Cameron Sheppard/)

Fish culvert in Issaquah. (Cameron Sheppard/)

King County fish culvert plan falls short in project prioritization

KC Auditor says that the county is doing lower priority projects first, putting higher ones at risk.

According to an audit presented to the King County Council on March 12, a 10-year plan laid out by King County to restore access to fish habitat by removing barriers — primarily road culverts — does not line up with the goal set by the county to open the best habitat for fish as fast as possible.

Fish barriers in King County and across the region can block or limit salmon and steelhead trout trying to return upstream to spawning grounds, contributing to their decline and threatening the treaty rights of tribes in Washington state.

The King County Auditor’s Office reviewed the Fish Passage Restoration Program (FPRP) to look at whether the program had the support to be effective, how the workplan aligned with county and regional goals, and how it supported broader salmon recovery efforts. Its findings were presented to the King County Council’s Government Accountability and Oversight Committee on March 12.

While the report found that the program is making progress, it also found a gap between long-term goals and scheduled projects.

“We are pleased that the Executive concurred with all of our recommendations so the County can amplify the work they are already doing to restore access to salmon habitats and engage thoroughly with local Tribes,” said Kymber Waltmunson, King County Auditor.

King County Executive Dow Constantine created the FPRP in 2018 as part of a broad commitment to salmon protection and honoring tribal treaty rights. The program is tasked with removing county owned fish passage barriers in local streams that block salmon from accessing habitat.

As part of its work, FPRP in 2021 created a model to assign “priority scores” to more than 900 fish passage barriers owned by the county based on habitat impact. The priority scores identify which barriers block access to the most and “best” salmon habitat.

However, the King County Auditor’s Office says that when the FPRP developed its 10-year workplan, it did not sequence barrier removals solely according to priority score. As a result, the program is completing lower impact projects before some higher impact projects.

“This sequencing doesn’t align with the county’s goal of opening the best habitat as fast as possible and puts more impactful projects at risk if there are funding or staffing shortages later,” the King County Auditor’s Office stated regarding the audit.

Other key takeaways from the Auditor’s report include:

- Although the FPRP consulted proactively with local tribes on some program elements, it did not consult with them when developing its 10-year workplan that sequences projects.

“Additionally, the program should ensure early involvement with tribal representatives when planning individual projects,” the auditor stated. “These improvements would further the County’s goals of partnering across governments and ensuring that individuals who are affected by county decisions are involved in the decision-making processes.”

- Additional gaps include the need for the FPRP to consider the impact of non-county-owned barriers when reporting miles of restored habitat, the need for the county to implement a plan for addressing non-county owned barriers that block access to habitat, and the need for a strategic plan that clarifies the program’s goals and objectives, the activities it will complete to reach those goals and objectives, and the measures it will use to track the program’s impact.

The audit makes eight recommendations:

- “The FPRP should ensure public-facing websites and reports accurately reflect the decision-making considerations and tradeoffs involved in its workplan development and the resulting schedule of projects.”

- “The FPRP should review and update its 10-year workplan to ensure it is aligned with county goals as well as with the program’s goals and objectives developed during strategic planning.”

- “The FPRP should develop and document a plan to ensure completion of habitat-focused projects if projects are delayed, cost estimates increase, or funding is otherwise constrained.”

- “The FPRP should develop, document, and communicate the results of performance measures that accurately reflect program outputs and outcomes for restoring fish passage, including the impact of non-county-owned barriers on program outcomes.”

- “The FPRP should develop, document, and begin implementing a strategic plan that clarifies the goals and objectives of the program and should work with Clean Water Health Habitat initiative staff and others to ensure FPRP goals and objectives are consistent with county goals for fish passage and habitat restoration. In developing its strategic plan, the FPRP should ensure the plan aligns with and supports efforts previously described.”

- “The King County Executive should develop, document, and implement a plan that includes the activities necessary to meet the fish habitat goal and progress measures outlined in the King County Clean Water Healthy Habitat Strategic Plan 2020-2025, such as removal of non-county barriers.”

- “The FPRP should develop, document, and implement a plan to ensure ongoing consultation with the local tribes, including consultation on the program’s workplan.”

The FPRP “should ensure” that the defined plan provides for “consultation with local tribes throughout a project’s life cycle.”


Talk to us

Please share your story tips by emailing editor@kentnews.us.

To share your opinion for publication, submit a letter through our website https://kentnews.us/submit-letter/. Include your name, address and daytime phone number. (We’ll only publish your name and hometown.) Please keep letters to 300 words or less.

More in Northwest

A Sound Transit fare ambassador checks with a light rail rider. COURTESY PHOTO, Sound Transit
Fare inspections at Sound Transit Link stations begin June 3

Passengers will need proof of payment within fare paid zones at boarding areas

Jeffrey Nelson at his trial May 16, 2024. (Photo by Ken Lambert / The Seattle Times / Pool)
Murder trial begins for Auburn Police officer Jeffrey Nelson

First officer in Washington to face a murder charge following the passage of Initiative 940.

Men serving halal food on Eid Mubarak 2024. Photo By Joshua Solorzano/Federal Way Mirror
Washington state passes Halal Food Consumer Protection Act

Federal Way Muslim activist details how this bill came about and why it is important

t
Head-on collision kills 31-year-old woman in Auburn

The fatal collision occurred May 11 in the area of I Street Northeast in north Auburn.

A screenshot of King County Councilmember Reagan Dunn speaking about a proposed amendment for the proposed $20 minimum wage ordinance. (Screenshot)
King County approves $20.29 minimum wage for unincorporated areas

Councilmember Reagan Dunn and more than a dozen business owners argued tips and health care expenses should be a part of the new wage. The council passed the ordinance without the amendment.

Reyna Hernandez (right) with her mother. Photo Courtesy of Ivonne Carillo-Hernandez
Friends of Renton's Reyna Hernandez detail her cheerful character

Friends in Renton considered her family and saw some warning signs of abuse prior to her murder.

t
Auburn Police arrest driver at Lea Hill Park for hitting woman | Video

Dashcam footage shows the pursuing officer deploying a PIT maneuver on the Honda Fit

Renton Regional Fire Authority. Courtesy image.
Firefighters extinguish large brush fire in Renton

Broke out Friday, April 19; could be seen from Interstate 405

File photo
Man, 22, dies from shooting at Auburn apartment complex

Police say: ‘This wasn’t a random act’

t
King County releases $3 million to help find shelter for the homeless

Tukwila to get $2 million, Burien $1 million; no other South County cities applied for funds